Primordial Black Holes as Dark Matter?

I was recently asked by a family friend “have you heard about this new idea that primordial black holes could explain dark matter?”

Well I hadn’t, so I did a little investigating and it’s a pretty clever idea. Part of the backstory here is “what can we do with gravitational waves?”, so that’s where I’ll start.

One of the surprising things about the very first direct observations of gravitational waves by LIGO is the masses of the constituent black holes. The first pair was 36 and 29 solar masses, the second was 14 and 8, and the third was 31 and 19. What was immediately understood to be important about these sources is that they are generally more massive than the other stellar-mass black holes we’re found previously (from X-ray studies, usually. Max there is 18 solar masses). Significantly, the larger mass ones should also be *less* likely, from stellar formation scenarios. So while we are only talking about 6 new black holes, we clearly need to know if that will pose a problem for stellar formation models. (there are also some issues in regard to the spins of these black holes, but I won’t go down that particular rabbit hole).

So people started looking at it, and found that it was generally possible to get these kinds of higher-mass black holes, but it did put some constraints on the formation scenarios. Basically, the problem is you need to make giant stars, which generally need to have low metallicity to form. However, the conditions that generate those stars (high star formation rate in the past) generally turn out to produce higher overall metallicity quicker. If you tune the star formation rate a bit so there are actually fewer large-mass stars, you reduce the overall metalicity so you can effectively create massive black holes. So it’s constraining, but not overly so.

But that’s actually not what I want to talk about – what about other formation scenarios for these black holes? Specifically, what about primordial black holes (PBH)? These are black holes that formed as a result of density fluctuations in the early universe. It turns out it’s pretty easy to produce black holes of this mass in this manner (and the spin, which I skipped talking about above, is a little easier to produce as well). So, cool, we have at least two different ways the universe can give us the black holes found by LIGO.

But, are there any other implications of primordial mass black hole production at this rate? Well, without a stellar companion, there would typically not be an accretion disk and we would have no way to observe these black holes. But of course – that’s exactly the condition we need for dark matter!

So, in a recent paper, Juan Garcia-Bellido and his collaborators (who include Sebastien Clesse, Andre Linde, and David Wands) have worked this out in a bit of detail (and apparently there are others working on this as well, such as Alexander Kashlinsky).

The idea that black holes (or other compact objects) could be a model for dark matter is not new, actually. We’ve been looking for microlensing due to compact objects in the galactic halo for years (these objects are called MACHOS), but have essentially found nothing. What’s interesting about their new models is the mass distribution for primordial black holes in the 10-100 range sits right in the region of parameter space which was has not been covered by previous studies:

As you can see in the figure (which comes from the paper), the lower limits on PBH have a gap in between the lower mass MACHO/EROS observations and the higher mass WMAP3/FIRAS observations. It looks to me like that gap peaks around 0.01 of a solar mass and carries up to around 100. Which is broad range for black holes, but look at the range which we are talking about here (25 orders of magnitude!).

So there are lots of other interested details here, but what’s really fascinating about this new paper is that there are apparently a very large set of phenomenological signals we can use to test this hypothesis. It would affect the CMB, star formation in the early universe, X-ray transients, and a whole host of others. One particularly interesting idea is that rather then looking for lensing, we might try to look for the shift of the positions of stars over time. With the new plethora of data on stellar positions (like the GAIA satellite), it also might be the first time someone could actually attempt such a study. So there are a lot of interesting things to check.

As a sidenote, some of these black holes would of course develop an accretion disk through random interactions with stars or gas, and produce point sources that would emit in Gamma or X-ray range. Well, there actually is a large list of unidentified point sources in nearly all the X-ray catalogs. In fact, my undergraduate honors thesis was working on trying to identify unknown point sources in a Chandra X-ray image of the galactic center. The paper suggests that rather than looking at spectral characteristics, one should look for a correlation between the point sources and the expected dark matter distribution.

So, we’ve got LIGO finding a new class of black holes, which could be created in the early universe, and a new model for dark matter. Given how much trouble the particle model for dark matter is having (sorry LHC!), we should be taking these new ideas seriously. And what’s great about this is there are *bunch* of great ways to look for this primordial black hole signal. Of course, maybe that means it won’t last long as an explanation for dark matter, but it’s something new to look at that doesn’t require any exotic new physics.

And, not to belabor the point, but all of this wouldn’t have been possible with LIGO. Thanks LIGO!



Add A Comment:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s